The New School -- Institute on Race, Power and Political Economy | Budget Equity Project logo

MassachusettsBoston

See how Boston performed on our equity assessment of its ARPA Local Fiscal Recovery Fund investment strategy.

Total Equity Focused ARPA Funds

$413,185,712$413,185,712

Overall Score

High

Featured Case Studies

Investing to Accelerate a Green New Deal

Building on its strong equity focus, Boston, Massachusetts is using ARPA funds to advance Mayor Michelle Wu’s vision for a Green New Deal, tackling climate change while addressing poverty and the racial wealth gap.

Creating an Ecosystem to Strengthen and Expand BIPOC-Owned Business

Boston, Massachusetts dedicated $9 million in ARPA recovery funds toward inclusive procurement, including the SCALE program: a new business accelerator that aims to increase city contracts with women and minority-owned businesses by building their capacity to compete for contracts in industries that represent areas of high municipal spending, such as construction, design, and food services.

ARPA Equity Assessment of Boston, MA

Overall Equity Focus

highHigh

Was racial and economic equity an explicit focus of the jurisdiction's ARPA investment strategy?

Equity Conscious
checkmark icon95% of locations met this criterion.
Race Conscious
checkmark icon81% of locations met this criterion.
Equity as a Priority
checkmark icon86% of locations met this criterion.

Equity Decision Making Tools and Resources

highHigh

Are equity tools, frameworks, and structures in place to support equitable investment project identification, design, and implementation?

Equity Principles
checkmark icon38% of locations met this criterion.

Boston established a set of key values to drive ARPA investment decisions that included: 1) advancing racial equity; 2) supporting transformative solutions to providing services; 3) creating good jobs in growing industries; 4) promoting climate justice; and 5) continuing equitable health responses. The City’s approach has emphasized prioritizing lower income residents of color most impacted by the pandemic and communicating with these underserved residents to ensure they can access the resources they need.

Equity Policies
checkmark icon24% of locations met this criterion.

In 2019, fomer-mayor Martin Walsh issued an executive order affirming the city’s commitment to racial equity. The executive order requires every city cabinet, department, agency, and office to apply a racial equity lens to their efforts and develop goals and strategies to advance racial equity. Additionally, in 2016, Boston passed a citywide language access policy.

Equity Framework
checkmark icon31% of locations met this criterion.

The City’s focus on equity in ARPA spending decisions built upon nearly two decades of work institutionalizing an equity focus throughout government operations, beginning in the health department and expanding to a citywide Resilience Strategy in 2017. The City is leveraging ARPA resources to actualize Mayor Wu’s vision for a local Green New Deal .

Equity Staffing
checkmark icon51% of locations met this criterion.

With 10 staff members, Boston’s Equity and Inclusion Cabinet works to transform policies, programs, and practices to benefit every Boston resident. In 2020, the City established the Chief of Equity and Inclusion position, which played a central role throughout the ARPA funding allocation process.

Equity Tools
x icon31% of locations met this criterion.
Data Disaggregation
checkmark icon48% of locations met this criterion.
Geographic Targeting via QCTs
checkmark icon72% of locations met this criterion.
Neighborhood Risk/Vulnerability Mapping
x icon38% of locations met this criterion.

Community Engagement

highHigh

Did the jurisdiction engage community members in decision making about the ARPA funds, conduct targeted outreach to historically excluded communities, and implement strategies to reach underserved communities?

Broad Community Engagement
checkmark icon94% of locations met this criterion.
Targeted Outreach
checkmark icon64% of locations met this criterion.
Inclusive Engagement
checkmark icon54% of locations met this criterion.

Equitable Labor Practices

highHigh

Does the jurisdiction use best practices for ensuring public investments deliver family-supporting jobs to residents who have faced barriers to good jobs and economic prosperity?

Targeted or Local Hiring
x icon36% of locations met this criterion.
Living Wage
checkmark icon16% of locations met this criterion.
Prevailing Wage
checkmark icon70% of locations met this criterion.
Project Labor Agreement
checkmark icon29% of locations met this criterion.
Community Benefits Agreements
checkmark icon11% of locations met this criterion.

Equity Investments

highHigh

Did the jurisdiction make investments that have the potential to advance equity by targeting the communities most harmed by the pandemic and addressing systemic inequities?

Good Jobs
checkmark icon62% of locations met this criterion.
Income and Wealth
checkmark icon71% of locations met this criterion.
Inclusive Business Development
checkmark icon64% of locations met this criterion.
Housing Security
checkmark icon82% of locations met this criterion.
Food Security
checkmark icon63% of locations met this criterion.
Health Equity
checkmark icon81% of locations met this criterion.
Digital Equity
checkmark icon45% of locations met this criterion.
Early Childhood
checkmark icon33% of locations met this criterion.
Quality Child Care
checkmark icon32% of locations met this criterion.
Youth & School-Aged Children
checkmark icon64% of locations met this criterion.
Community Infrastructure
checkmark icon64% of locations met this criterion.
Equity Infrastructure
checkmark icon31% of locations met this criterion.
Community Based Organizations
checkmark icon67% of locations met this criterion.
Community Safety & Justice
checkmark icon56% of locations met this criterion.
Policing (Negative Points)
x icon50% of locations met this criterion.
Extent of Investment (% of Spending)
79%46% is the average across all locations.
Extent of Investment (% of Projects)
92%58% is the average across all locations.

Transparency & Accountability

highHigh

Does the jurisdiction set performance goals, collect data to monitor progress toward equitable outcomes, and provide the public with information about how funds are being used?

Equity Outcomes
checkmark icon55% of locations met this criterion.
Public Data
checkmark icon70% of locations met this criterion.
ARPA Website
checkmark icon64% of locations met this criterion.
Performance Measures
checkmark icon75% of locations met this criterion.

The Equity Focus of Boston's ARPA Investments

Primary Policy Area
Amount
Percentage
Housing security
$160,648,373
30.8%
Health equity
$66,903,273
12.8%
Inclusive business development
$58,017,533
11.1%
Community infrastructure
$56,578,000
10.8%
Quality child care
$17,320,000
3.3%
Good jobs
$15,950,000
3.1%
Community-based organizations
$8,001,727
1.5%
Youth and school-aged children
$7,375,000
1.4%
Food security
$5,886,025
1.1%
Equity infrastructure
$5,699,781
1.1%
Income and wealth
$5,300,000
1.0%
Digital equity
$4,000,000
0.8%
Community safety and justice
$1,506,000
0.3%
Not equity focused or unknown
$108,604,694
20.8%

$413,185,712

  of $521,790,406 funds budgeted as of July 2023 (79.2%) were equity focused
View Detailed Investments